Critics strongly disagree. Many mental health experts warn that hopelessness is a symptom of depression and question whether a desire for death can ever be fully autonomous in such cases. Others fear a slippery slope, arguing that allowing euthanasia for psychiatric conditions risks normalizing death as a response to psychological distress rather than investing in better mental health care.
Her case has not settled the debate, but it has forced a global audience to confront difficult questions about suffering, choice, and where society should draw its most fragile moral lines.